Shingles More Condition_symptoms Photos What Is More Sound Proof, A Cedar Shake Roof Or Asphalt Shingles?

What is more sound proof, a cedar shake roof or asphalt shingles? - shingles more condition_symptoms photos

Considerering cedar roof, I think 30 pounds and 30 years security sub-layer roof. We live near an airport, if the sound is important. Do I have more or less noise asphalt roofs?